Alloy designations present unique challenges for aerospace procurement teams. A common source of confusion is AMS 5659 and 15CDV6. Both alloys are used in high-performance engineering, but they have different uses and come from different metallurgical families. The differences between the two alloys become important when procuring critical components made from bar, plate, or tubular stock. Wrong grades delivered to your location can result in scrapped parts, failed inspections, and costly delays in the supply chain.
AMS 5659 is 15-5PH, a type of precipitation-hardening stainless steel, and is in competition with the more popular grade, 17-4PH (AMS 5643), of the martensitic PH stainless steels. A key differentiator is the composition of the alloys. 15-5PH has a different balance of chromium, nickel and copper which results in the ferrite-forming delta phase present in 17-4PH being replaced. This results in a more uniform microstructure throughout the thickness of the bar. This consistency is a key differentiator for manufacturers of highly stressed rotating elements, shafts or fittings, especially when the transverse mechanical properties are as critical as the longitudinal ones.
The material 15-5PH supplied and heat-treated to various condition callouts, from H900 to H1150, presents strength and toughness moving in opposite directions with increasing ageing temperature. For high-load, low-temperature applications, a specification at a lower H-condition is desired, due to the increased tensile strength. Conversely, for better fracture toughness or fatigue resistance, a higher ageing temperature is preferred, with a slight decrease in yield strength. Fabricators of AMS 5659 must not only review the base specification, but also the condition and any additional requirements around grain flow, ultrasonic inspection, and magnetic particle testing. These requirements are very distinct from client to client and depend on the application.
15CDV6 is different. It is a low-alloy chromium-molybdenum-vanadium steel, akin to the more common 4130 and 4140 grades, but is specially designed for welded aerospace structures, motorsport chassis, and high-pressure gas cylinders. Its main attribute is its outstanding weldability and the high strength it attains from heat treatment. This makes it ideal where fabricators must weld thin-walled tubing into intricate structures or pressure vessels while still maintaining strong mechanical performance in the heat-affected zone. While 15-5PH is selected for corrosion resistance and strength in a machined/forged component, 15CDV6 is selected where a structure must be welded and subsequently normalised or heat-treated as an assembly.
The ramifications of sourcing materials differ case by case. When sourcing 15-5PH, the stockholder must provide full traceability to melt-and-heat treatments; backward traceability concerning the stockholder is critical to meet aerospace quality systems. For sourcing 15CDV6, the focus becomes the tube wall tolerances, seamless versus welded tubes (if there is a seam, it must be specified), and the post-weld heat treatment (which must be specified if it is to be performed internally or by an approved subcontractor).
There is also substantial responsibility placed upon suppliers of these materials, and their responsibility is greater than administrative completeness. They are responsible for whether the stockholder provides complete test reports that include the chemical composition and the mechanical properties for the batch you’re actually receiving and not an arbitrary test report. It is also up to the stockholder to ensure that the heat treatment and non-destructive testing certifications are provided if they are required. If a revision of AMS 5659 or the 15CDV6 Spec is cited on a drawing, it is critical to reference that revision in your documentation because the certificates are subject to audits based on their date, so the older certificates will not be accepted.
In the end, deciding on these grades or specifying any one of them correctly, depends on aligning the metallurgy with the actual service requirement rather than adhering to convention. Talking with a knowledgeable steel stockholder at the outset of the design or purchasing stages can help to avoid a lot of the later time setbacks associated with lead times, minimum order quantities, and the availability of unusual bar sizes or wall thicknesses for these specialty grades.
Leave a Reply